Skip to main content

Atheist Delusions: Another book review

In Beirut airport there is a smallish bookstore containing a smallish English language section, containing a few John Grisham novels, some travelogues, a good number of books on Islam and this: Atheist Delusions, The Christian Revolution and its Fashionable Enemies, by David Bentley Hart. I bought it immediately, and discovered at this point that my Visa card was still in an ATM back in Ashrifiyeh, but that is another story. I started to read the book on the plane and discovered a new hero.

David Bentley Hart is an Orthodox (note the capital)theologian of immense erudition, intellectual capacity and wit. I have now ordered some of his other works, but this one proved to be a great way to fill the long hours drifting above the clouds. His way of dealing with the challenge of the new Atheism is one I warm to immensely. I have long known that the best way of dealing with Atheist splutter is to use their own non-arguments against them ( I used to be an atheist but in my early twenties found that I no longer needed the emotional crutch of atheism...) Hart does it better. He knows what many of us timid and polite and nice Christians simply don't: that most of the atheists who beset us with such assurance and confidence simply have no idea what they're talking about. So people with the skimpiest knowledge of history, and no understanding whatsoever of the history of science will regale us with absolutely confident and convinced opinions on, say, the trial of Galileo. People whose knowledge of the Middle Ages comes exclusively from some half baked TV documentary or from one or two badly researched best sellers will argue earnestly about the end of the Roman Empire and the theological and moral development of Europe. With style, panache, élan, learning and relentless logic David Bentley Hart demolishes... no, blends, powders and atomizes... the arguments raised not so much by the serious philosophical atheists (of whom, incidentally there are precious few about), but by the fashionable poseurs, the headline makers, the publishers of cheap and cheerful splentetic tomes, and the ABWFI (Adolescent Boys With Father Issues [my phrase]).

The style of the book is bold, confident and assured. It is a wonderful piece of Christian apologetic, but it is much more besides. It is an interesting potted history of Christianity and of the development of Scientific thinking, written by a man acknowledged as one of the world's foremost scholars of religion. It is a devastating critique of the West, and of Modernism as the prevailing philosophy of the West. It is a hope-full analysis of the Christian Gospel and a statement of its contribution to the intellectual and moral development of Europe and, indeed, of the world. The book is backed by impressive scholarship, properly footnotes and referenced, and all this presented in a readable, and even racy style.

Hart's analysis of Modernism as resting on a particular concept of freedom is an intriguing one, and this is an idea I have spent the last few weeks unpacking for myself. Hart describes the Modernist concept of freedom as being entirely about the individual: that is, MY development as an individual is the highest good, and anything which compromises MY right to do exactly as I please is to be resisted. I believe he is accurate in this, and I am alarmed to consider how far this particular view of freedom has infiltrated the church and influenced the way we organize ourselves and the way we think about life, the universe and everything. We have lost, in large measure the freedom described by Paul in Romans which is freedom from my own self absorption and from the impulses and half conscious powers and principalities which hold me locked down tight in bondage.

This is a book I am savoring until The Beauty of the Infinite arrives. It's one I recommend highly, but don't expect me to lend you my copy. Not just yet, anyway.


Merv said…
..... not wanting to get carried away (he said) but I believe we are led to some books in a slightly miraculous way.
In some American city (could have been Miami or New Haven) in an ordinary book store, Kathleen Norris' Amazing Grace - A Vocabulary of Faith beamed at me and said 'pick me'.
I'd never heard of or read her before. I sure have now.
Wynston said…
Oh dear ... yet another 'must have' book, and my copy of "A 30 Day Retreat" hasn't even arrived!
Kelvin Wright said…
Kathleen Norris is a great read. Dakota is the one of hers I responded most to, but Amazing Grace is not far behind.

And sorry about adding to the book bill, Wynston. Tell Lorraine it's my fault.
Anonymous said…
Hart has written a fine book here (one that even bends over backwards to be fair to Julian the Apostate in his attempted revival of paganism), with a great cavalcade of thinkers and movements. Of course, he's Orthodox and isn't too kind to Protestants.
A lot of Hart's other work can be accessed (free!) from the 'First Things' and 'Touchstone' websites. His work can be compared with Dante scholar Tony Esolen of Providence College.
Anonymous said…
Here's a new piece by Hart on 'the new atheism':

Lee said…
I don't *get* atheism - but then, I guess I haven't had the time to properly read their books and listen to their, no doubt, convincing arguments.

For me, the Divine has just always been there, and always will be. Doesn't stop me cursing at Him/Her and doesn't stop me from questioning either!

But I'm not pigheaded enough to presume that humans have anywhere like enough brains to ever understand the complexities and elegant simplicities of the universe.

We've a long, long way to go, and a bit of humility would do us good.

Where am I going with this? I suppose I just see atheist as another form of "listen-to-me-ism", and a particularly vitriolic, aggressive, testosterone-laden one. Why so desperate to convince? Why so desperate to be heard?

Like I said, I don't get it! I'd rather just go out, and sit under a beautiful tree, and listen to the wind singing songs far more beautiful than anything I'll ever sing.
Jason Goroncy said…
Kelvin, thanks for posting this review on what is a very helpful book. I thought that while you're waiting for The Beauty of the Infinite to arrive, you may really appreciate Marilynne Robinson's latest book (based on her Terry Lectures), Absence of Mind: The Dispelling of Inwardness from the Modern Myth of the Self. I found it a great compliment to Hart's insightful analysis. Happy to loan you my copy too.
Kelvin Wright said…
Thanks Brian for the link. The article gives a god taste of Hart's style and depth. Thanks also, Jason, for the suggestion of Marilynne Robinson. I looked her up on Amazon, read a review or two (the most telling of which was the rabbit in the headlights panic ridden squealing of the atheists) and bought an electronic copy which I have begun reading on the Kindle reader of my iPad. Isn't technology wonderful?
Jason Goroncy said…
Yes it is. I look forward to reading your thoughts on Robinson's book, should you choose to post on it. Pax.
Anonymous said…
We weren't,we are, we're not,face it.
NIE said…
Thanks Kelvin and Brian. Have just come upon something David B. Hart wrote a couple of days ago on First Things, about the Julian the "Apostate" - Julian Our Contemporary
Aug 6, 2010

Popular posts from this blog

Centering Prayer Retreat

    A 3 day taught retreat in the practice of Centering Prayer.   Saturday October 2 2021 - Monday October 4 2021 Centering Prayer is a form of Christian silent contemplative prayer. This retreat is suitable for beginners in silent prayer, or for more experienced practitioners wishing to refresh their practice.  The retreat will be held in the En Hakkore retreat centre in the hills above Waipiata in the Maniototo. There will be daily sessions of silent prayer, instruction and discussion. The venue is spacious and set in an expansive landscape. there will be some time for personal reflection.  The cost is $175 per person which includes 2 nights accommodation and all meals.   Since the beginning, following the example of Jesus, there has been a tradition of silent prayer in the Christian Church. Over the centuries this tradition faded from the popular view and became confined to monasteries. It was kept alive by a largely ignored, but never fading lineage of Christian contemplatives.  

Turn Sideways Into The Light

David Whyte speaks in his audio series What To Remember When Waking of the myth of the Tuatha De Danann. They were a mythical race from Ireland's past who were tall, magical, mystical people devoted to beauty and artistry. When another more brutal people, the Milesians invaded Ireland the Tuatha De Danann fought them off in two battles, but were faced with a third, decisive battle against overwhelming odds. So, lined up in battle formation and facing almost certain defeat, the Tuatha De Danann turned sideways into the light and disappeared. Whyte's retelling is, to put it mildly, a gloss, but I am quite taken with the phrase and with the phenomenon it describes. Turning sideways into the light is the realisation that there are some encounters that are damaging to all involved in them: no one wins a war. Faced with such an exchange, to turn sideways into the light is to seek another, more whole form of relationship. It is to reject the ground rules of the conversation as they

En Hakkore

In the hills up behind Ranfurly there used to be a town, Hamilton, which at one stage was home to 5,000 people. All that remains of it now is a graveyard, fenced off and baking in the lonely brown hills. Near it, in the 1930s a large Sanitorium was built for the treatment of tuberculosis and other respiratory ailments. It was a substantial complex of buildings with wards, a nurses hostel, impressive houses for the manager and superintendent and all the utility buildings needed for such a large operation. The treatment offered consisted of isolation, views and weather. Patients were exposed to the air, the tons of it which whistled past, often at great speed, the warmth of the sun and the cold. They were housed in small cubicles opening onto huge glassed verandas where they cooked in the summer and froze in the winter and often, what with the wholesome food and the exercise, got better. When advances in antibiotics rendered the Sanitorium obsolete it was turned into a Borstal and the

Camino, by David Whyte

This poem captures it perfectly Camino. The way forward, the way between things, the way already walked before you, the path disappearing and re-appearing even as the ground gave way beneath you, the grief apparent only in the moment of forgetting, then the river, the mountain, the lifting song of the Sky Lark inviting you over the rain filled pass when your legs had given up, and after, it would be dusk and the half-lit villages in evening light; other people's homes glimpsed through lighted windows and inside, other people's lives; your own home you had left crowding your memory as you looked to see a child playing or a mother moving from one side of a room to another, your eyes wet with the keen cold wind of Navarre. But your loss brought you here to walk under one name and one name only, and to find the guise under which all loss can live; remember you were given that name every day along the way, remember you were greeted as such, and you neede


This photo was taken by my daughter Catherine, when I was about 50. I think she did a pretty good job.  The number 70 has a kind of Biblical gravitas. It’s the number of elders appointed by Moses to lead the recalcitrant Israelites, and the number of people who went down to join Joseph, in Egypt. Jesus sent 70 disciples out to minister in his name, and the first Jewish Sanhedrin had 70 blokes in it. And, of course, there is Psalm 90:10:  “ The days of our life are threescore years and ten, and if by reason of strength they be fourscore, yet is their strength labour and sorrow, for it is soon cut off and we fly away ”. All this has some personal import because I turn 70 today, and can no longer fool myself that I am middle aged. I’m old. And before you feed me one of the lines of balderdash that pass for wisdom in our culture - “you’re only as old as you feel”; “70 is the new 50”; “age is just a number” or some other such nonsense, let me tell you that I am happy to be old. Deliriously