Skip to main content

The Extraordinary Powers of Scapegoats

Jews being murdered during the Black Death in Poland, for which they were blamed
Many years ago I was Vicar of a rural parish spread over about 1000 square miles of South Canterbury. For about two years there was a very strong El Nino weather system in the Pacific Ocean and our parish suffered its worst drought in many decades. One day a parishioner, who had, many assured me, a prophetic gift, asked to see me. He told me that God had spoken to him and revealed that the reason for the drought was that there were too many Freemasons on our parish vestry and that God was withholding the rain until we did something about that.

Knowing the men he was talking about, I personally doubted that the Almighty was unduly concerned at them trying to serve their church by attending a meeting or two every month, and I was astonished, now as then, at what he was claiming for about 3 or 4  rather nice middle aged sheep farmers in one of the remoter parts of New Zealand: That by attending their local lodge, going through their set rituals, having a few beers and discussing what good works to spend their donations on, somehow had the power to affect a vast and complex weather system which involved such things as shifts in atmospheric pressure in Indonesia and Peru and the salinity of the ocean in the North Pacific which in turn affected the flows of currents up the coast of South America.

When a community becomes unstable because the mimetic forces which drew it together inevitably cause escalating competition, the primary mechanism for restablising it, says Rene Girard, is scapegoating. That is, the community blames someone or a group of someones - the scapegoat/s -and by getting rid of the scapegoat, get rid of their problem. In doing this the community is attributing supernatural, almost Godlike power on the scapegoat. These not quite arbitrarily selected people are capable of  all manner of huge and dastardly deeds. They make the crops fail or the rain to stop falling or the black death to kill vast numbers of people. They cause World Wars or influence the international banking system. They make little children ill and curdle the milk. They become the personification of all that is maleficent.

And when the community focuses on the scapegoat and works to rid themselves of the danger they pose, an extraordinary thing happens. The community is actually stablised. The problems do disappear. Our society, for example  has probably never been so united and cohesive as when we all joined together to fight the Germans or the Japanese. And when the Germans hated the Jews they did find a new sense of national identity, and the trains did run on time. Poor white people in the United States are currently feeling an increase in cohesion, purpose and power as they face the Muslim "threat".

Scapegoating actually works, at least for a time. Of course the real problems do not disappear and the instability will return at some stage, but there will always be a new scapegoat that can be identified and punished for the evils which have befallen the community. And in the meantime the old scapegoat is remembered: there is their enormous power to inflict evil, and, paradoxically, there is their power to effect the rectification of that evil through their death or banishment. And as the tale is told, the power of the scapegoat for both good and evil increase with the telling until the two parts of this paradoxical load of power becomes too big for one scapegoat to carry. At this stage in the telling of the story the scapegoat divides to become an evil presence, causing the problems of society and a good presence, effecting  salvation from those problems. A myth is formed, and retold, and grows with the years.

Behind every myth, says Girard, is an actual historical act of violence against some unfortunate victim deep in the history of the myth telling culture. These myths are codified in religions: all religion he says, has its origin in violence. Every myth, upon analysis can be shown to derive from some actual act of scapegoating and will reveal itself to sit on a well described path of development from raw act to sophisticated story. These myths serve to reinforce the values which the society cherishes as their founding principles. All serve to reinforce the position  of  those in power and to justify the violence by which that power is stabilised. There is one exception, however. The Judaeo - Christian system follows quite another path. Remind me to tell you about it sometime.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ko Tangata Tiriti Ahau

    The Christmas before last our kids gave us Ancestry.com kits. You know the deal: you spit into a test tube, send it over to Ireland, and in a month or so you get a wadge of paper in the mail telling you who you are. I've never, previously, been interested in all that stuff. I knew my forbears came to Aotearoa in the 1850's from Britain but I didn't know from where, exactly. Clemency's results, as it turns out, were pretty interesting. She was born in England, but has ancestors from various European places, and some who are Ngāti Raukawa, so she can whakapapa back to a little marae called Kikopiri, near Ōtaki. And me? It turns out I'm more British than most British people. Apart from a smattering of Norse  - probably the result of some Viking raid in the dim distant past - all my tūpuna seem to have come from a little group of villages in Nottinghamshire.  Now I've been to the UK a few times, and I quite like it, but it's not home: my heart and soul belon...

En Hakkore

In the hills up behind Ranfurly there used to be a town, Hamilton, which at one stage was home to 5,000 people. All that remains of it now is a graveyard, fenced off and baking in the lonely brown hills. Near it, in the 1930s a large Sanitorium was built for the treatment of tuberculosis and other respiratory ailments. It was a substantial complex of buildings with wards, a nurses hostel, impressive houses for the manager and superintendent and all the utility buildings needed for such a large operation. The treatment offered consisted of isolation, views and weather. Patients were exposed to the air, the tons of it which whistled past, often at great speed, the warmth of the sun and the cold. They were housed in small cubicles opening onto huge glassed verandas where they cooked in the summer and froze in the winter and often, what with the wholesome food and the exercise, got better. When advances in antibiotics rendered the Sanitorium obsolete it was turned into a Borstal and...

Why I Hold the Views I Do

St. Hilda's Collegiate School, taken with my phone after a recent meeting. This picture has nothing whatsoever to do with what follows, but I like the interplay of shapes and particularly the shadow on the wall. My mother is a Methodist, liberal in her theological and social opinions. My father was a socialist, just slightly to the left, in his politics, of Karl Marx. My siblings -there are 5 of us- are all bright, eloquent and omnivorous in their consumption of books and other intellectual fodder.  One of my most cherished childhood memories is of mealtimes in our little state house. The food was ingested with copious amounts of spirited, opinionated, clever and sometimes informed debate on whatever subject happened to catch the attention of one of the family that day. Or whatever one of us thought might get a rise out of someone else. So, sex, politics and religion it was then - oh and motorbikes, economics, international relations, demographics, cricket, company ownersh...

The Traitor

A couple of people have questioned me privately about the Leonard Cohen song The Traitor , and about Cohen's comments on the song, "[The Traitor is about] the feeling we have of betraying some mission we were mandated to fulfill and being unable to fulfill it; then coming to understand that the real mandate was not to fulfill it; and the real courage is to stand guiltless in the predicament in which you find yourself". What on earth does he mean, and why am I so excited about it? For the latter, check with my psychiatrist. For the former, my take on the song is this: The Traitor is another of those instances, as in The Partisan , where Leonard Cohen uses a military metaphor to speak of life in general and human love in particular. Many of us hold high ideals: some great quest or other that we pursue. These are often laudable things: finding true love, finding the absolute love of God, becoming enlightened, spreading the Gospel, writing the great novel or some such ...

Camino, by David Whyte

This poem captures it perfectly Camino. The way forward, the way between things, the way already walked before you, the path disappearing and re-appearing even as the ground gave way beneath you, the grief apparent only in the moment of forgetting, then the river, the mountain, the lifting song of the Sky Lark inviting you over the rain filled pass when your legs had given up, and after, it would be dusk and the half-lit villages in evening light; other people's homes glimpsed through lighted windows and inside, other people's lives; your own home you had left crowding your memory as you looked to see a child playing or a mother moving from one side of a room to another, your eyes wet with the keen cold wind of Navarre. But your loss brought you here to walk under one name and one name only, and to find the guise under which all loss can live; remember you were given that name every day along the way, remember you were greeted as such, and you neede...