Skip to main content

God is a Woman



My daughter Catherine has, as part of her life’s mission, taken on my musical education. She recommends artists to me, and by and large she’s pretty accurate in knowing what I will respond to, so, a month or so ago, when she sent me a link to the song above, Ariana Grande’s God is a Woman, I watched it. It’s the exception which proves the rule I guess. I thought the song was crap, and explained my reasons why to Catherine. A dull, repetitive, unimaginative, unoriginal tune. Clumsy, inelegant, monodimensional  lyrics. A video full of kitschy religious iconography, kind of like an animated facebook meme of the type that tells you to share to prove you love your Mom. Catherine told me I was being a pretentious old man (she is right on all three counts, of course ) and asked what did I expect from a 23 year old pop singer? She said that the video was valuable for the conversations it would generate. The video has beeen viewed, as of today, 84.5 million times, been liked 2.3 million times, disliked 297 thousand times and generated countless pages of comments, some of which were breathlessly adulatory, and almost all of which commented on the religious meaning of the song. Yep, Catherine, you're right. That’s a somewhat wider reach than the average Anglican sermon, alright. So I viewed the thing again. Downloaded the lyrics. Viewed it yet again.

Let’s be clear here, the song isn’t actually about spirituality, it’s about sex. The bottom line, take home message is that Ariana Grande is divinely good in bed. She’s so good, in fact that the lucky, unnamed recipient of her favours is going to be remade, and will worship her for reshaping him. I guess we’ll all have to take her word on that one. The video, considered apart from the lyrics, is another matter. It is a series of religious scenes segueing into one another, some  of which echo iconic images from the world religions. So Ariana Grande stands in a swirl of white clad (female) pilgrims, reminiscent of the swirl of white clad Muslim men around the Kaaba, or writhes in the flame of a candle (light of the world, geddit) or sings from behind a large group of (woman) meditators. She straddles the world and fiddles with a hurricane. A couple of the images are memorable: her goddess figure sits serenely and powerfully in a stylised city while a group of angry little men throw words at her. She takes a Thor like hammer and throws it upward to smash the glass ceiling of a basilica. The images are, of course, not about divinity. What is pictured is not God but a demiurge: her goddess is Wonder Woman on steroids. But I guess that’s exactly the point. 

What Ariana Grande has done is take a number of common images of God and change only one detail: the gender of the central figure. In doing this, the fact that the images are engineered around her particular sexual and political agenda is blatantly obvious. Which casts a glaring searchlight on the icons on which hers are based. If the imagery in her video had men at the centre they would be seen as well produced but unexceptional pieces of religious kitsch. God is a Woman exposes what most people take for granted most of the time: the unconscious and therefore unexamined sexual and political agendas which inform our own metaphorical portrayals of God.

Finally, there is, in this video an odd paradox.  The strong juxtaposition of spiritual and sexual imagery invite the  implication that the ultimate worth of a woman is tied to her sexual power over men. I doubt Ariana Grande intended this point, though her  lyrics strongly suggest otherwise. All of us think we are free from being shaped by personal, biological, cultural and political agendas. All of us are mistaken on that point and the messages implicit in our communications, obvious to everyone except ourselves, are the ones of which we need to be especially cautious.

Comments

Mr Truman said…
While a little simplistic, I prefer Gungor’s “God is not a White Man” for musing on a similar idea with fewer mixed-messages and sexualised images. - https://youtu.be/-WybvhRu9KU
15 August 2018 at 22:34
Kate said…
As usual you tease out ideas and make me think. But in this case, and even making the assumption that everyone who sees/ hears this vid would extract such a useful lesson from it, do the ends justify the means? Or is it still mostly just crap?
22 August 2018 at 09:53
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

How To Walk 800 km

John is just walking the 80 metres back to his bike here, but you get the general drift.  The question I get asked more than any other at the end of the Hikoi is "how are your feet?" It's nice that people care, but my feet have never been an issue on long walks. Good shoes and socks prevent blisters and cushion the effects of long distances on hard surfaces, but I have had other issues. When walking the Camino Santiago knees, Achilles tendons and shin splints have all at one time or another given me trouble. This time round, these have all been fine and I finished feeling as though I could just keep on going indefinitely; to Cape Reinga if needs be. Over the last couple of years I have learned 6 things that have made all the difference. Namely: 1. Footwear. On the Camino I wore walking shoes - Salomon in 2009 and Asics in 2012. A year ago I changed to full walking boots - Salomon Cosmic 2 - and the difference was instant and major. When walking more than 15 minutes...
1 comment
Read more

Why I Hold the Views I Do

St. Hilda's Collegiate School, taken with my phone after a recent meeting. This picture has nothing whatsoever to do with what follows, but I like the interplay of shapes and particularly the shadow on the wall. My mother is a Methodist, liberal in her theological and social opinions. My father was a socialist, just slightly to the left, in his politics, of Karl Marx. My siblings -there are 5 of us- are all bright, eloquent and omnivorous in their consumption of books and other intellectual fodder.  One of my most cherished childhood memories is of mealtimes in our little state house. The food was ingested with copious amounts of spirited, opinionated, clever and sometimes informed debate on whatever subject happened to catch the attention of one of the family that day. Or whatever one of us thought might get a rise out of someone else. So, sex, politics and religion it was then - oh and motorbikes, economics, international relations, demographics, cricket, company ownersh...
47 comments
Read more

I See Satan Fall Like Lightning

It happens sometimes. I have a question or am pondering some conundrum or other and the right book arrives at pretty much the right time. In a session with my supervisor a few months back Paul mentioned an article by Rene Girard, whom I had never heard of. I read the article and over the past month have read two of his books, The Scapegoat and this one. I have another couple sitting on my shelf and they have elbowed all others in my to be read pile out of the way and sit firmly on the top. Girard has pulled a number of threads together for me: he has enabled me to rethink the atonement in a way which is consistent with an evolving Universe: he presents a view of scripture which is again consistent with what I know of science but is also faithful to the Bible as the Word of God; he has given me, for the first time in my life a theology (if that is the right word) of Satan which makes sense to me. Most importantly for me, he is consistent with my own lived experience of God's s...
2 comments
Read more

2 More Years

An autumn leaf, the evidence of the death whereby the grapevine lives and bears fruit There are 31,102 verses in the Bible, or at least in the Protestant version of it which the conservative section of our church recognises. Of these, there are 6 verses which explicitly condemn homosexual practice. The best scholars in the Christian world have pointed out the ambiguity of even these scraps of scripture, but this does not prevent their becoming the basis of an antipathy to contemporary same gender sexuality which I was repeatedly told, during General Synod, was "First Order". I'm not sure what "First Order" means exactly, but I was told that this is a "Salvation Matter". So, presumably, holding a proper view on homosexuality is right up there in importance with belief in the doctrines I would consider foundational for the Christian faith: namely the Holy Trinity, Incarnation and Resurrection. In any event, antipathy to homosexuality has already ...
25 comments
Read more

Wood Pigeon

On the front lawn There is a bundle of green and white feathers. A woodpigeon. A dead one. We have a lot of trees in our neighbourhood and a very busy road, which is not a good combination for wood pigeons. They are great big ungainly birds and before they have acquired a sense of self preservation the young ones are inclined to accidental jousts with cars. The cars seldom lose. This bird has just won the silver medal in a bout with a Toyota Camry and has retired as far as our front lawn before becoming considerably short of breath. I go out with a shovel and dig a hole in the flower garden, and go a pick up the carcase. I love these birds. Their feathers have a rich metallic sheen, and the green and white of their plumage reflects back every shade of red - but just in suggestion, depending on how the sunlight catches them. They are preposterous in their clumsiness. They fly overhead with no pretense at stealth, making a sound like a pair of old fashioned manual hedge cutters with eac...
25 comments
Read more